wasting bandwidth since 1999

Ask The Experts

In a recent article, The Atlantic asks Can Schools Be Fixed?. To answer that very broad, completely open ended, and very non-specific question, they went to the “experts”.

Experts like a professor of economics at MIT, the lead education blogger for NPR, a Washington Post reporter, a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, an “Emerson senior fellow” (who also writes for the Atlantic), the founder and chairman of IDEO (a design firm), and the presidents of the NEA and AFT. Plus Diane Ravitch, Linda Darling-Hammond, and the CEO of DonorsChoose, all of whom might actually have some expertise to bring to this discussion.

However, completely missing from this particular panel of “experts”, as always, is anyone currently working with K12 students at any level. Not a teacher, no school administrators. Instead we have college professors, leaders of advocacy groups, professional writers, and news reporters. People who may be parents but still only have an outside-looking-in-the-classroom-window view of the education process.

And, of course, the Atlantic editors included no kids. Because we certainly can’t ask any actual students what’s wrong (or right) with their education and what could be done to “fix” their school.

Previous

Opportunities, Not Resolutions

Next

Performing Mathematics

1 Comment

  1. I can’t read these sorts of articles. The framing of education as failing and needing to be saved is absurd. Are there problems in education? Yes. Is it failing? For some kids, yes. For many kids, no. I firmly believe we could make far more progress much more quickly if we stopped with all the shaming of education and focused on what is genuinely happening. (But I might be overly sensitive.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Powered by WordPress & Theme by Anders Norén