Even with all the budget problems states and local school systems have had over the past few years, instructional technology still seems to grab more than its fair share of the budget. The dot com revolution may have gone bust but computers in the classroom are still hot. The question left unanswered, however, is: do these tools actually improve teaching and learning?
According to the largest international study of its kind, they don’t. Researchers from the Royal Economic Society in England came to the conclusion that the less students used computers, both at home and at school, the better their literacy and math skills.
Despite numerous claims by politicians and software vendors to the contrary, the evidence so far suggests that computer use in schools does not seem to contribute substantially to students’ learning of basic skills such as maths or reading.
Indeed, the more pupils used computers, the worse they performed, said Thomas Fuchs and Ludger Wossmann of Munich University.
Their report also noted that being able to use a computer at work – one of the justifications for devoting so much teaching time to ICT (information and communications technology) – had no greater impact on employability or wage levels than being able to use a telephone or a pencil.
The data for the study came from the background information on 100,000 students who participated in the Program for International Student Assessment (PISA). At the time of its release, many government and school officials jumped on the results to claim that just more computer usage led to better learning (re: higher test scores), especially among those kids with computers at home.
This is a good example of how one set of data can be interpreted in different ways to support different conclusions. However, both sides of the issue are missing the point. Too much of anything, including computers, is going to be harmful. As the Society researchers noted, students logging the most time on computers at home, scored lowest on the test, probably because that time was spent on games not school work.
The bottom line here is that the computer is not a magic wand to improve education any more than it’s a barrier to learning. Instructional technology is a tool, one that, in general, we’ve done a pretty poor job of using for education. A computer, with a few pieces of good software and connected to the web, brings an incredible potential for creative communications, both for teachers and students. But that potential is not packed in the box.
Too many schools systems have spent boat loads of cash on boxes and wires thinking that just dropping everything into their classrooms would magically changes things. However, most teachers, being in various stages of technology understanding, had little or no idea of how to make the best use of these devices in their teaching. And they rarely received good, continuous training to make it happen. The money for staff development was just not in the budget.
The overly large district for which I work is still buying lots of computers every year, trying to saturate the schools with as much technology as we can afford. And we have some teachers doing fantastic, very creative things with these tools. But even in this area that is supposed to be highly "tech savvy", I would venture that a large chunk of this equipment will be obsolete before it gets much use beyond the electronic typewriter/surf-the-web level.
Personally, I can’t imagine teaching today without continual access to computing devices (think beyond the desktop!). However, constant access doesn’t mean constant use. Learning when and how to use technology tools in the classroom is a difficult task and not one that comes as standard equipment in the box. When enough teachers have that knowledge, there will be plenty of proof that computers do improve and enhance student learning.
Pingback: JennyD
It makes me wince to see how much time kids spend in computer lab, googling and then cutting-and-pasting stuff they barely read into PowerPoint presentations! It’s like teaching them how to plagiarize!
I agree 100% with your post. However, this:
“Their report also noted that being able to use a computer at work – one of the justifications for devoting so much teaching time to ICT (information and communications technology) – had no greater impact on employability or wage levels than being able to use a telephone or a pencil.”
struck me as a strong argument in *favor* of computers in the classroom. I mean, if I didn’t know how to use a telephone or a pencil, my employment prospects would be somewhat limited, no? All I can say is that the sentence doesn’t exactly display strong reasoning.
My own (recent) experience as a student with computers in the classroom was underwhelming. It was great to have a computer lab in my high school so that we could check email, work on papers at the last minute, and so forth. But in class, the teachers never really did much with the computers, and when they did it seemed superfluous. (The one exception was a C++ programming class, which used computers all the time and was excellent.) In any case, my education didn’t suffer.
Pingback: Land of the Lemmings, v2 » More computers make students learn?
Very good analysis of using computer to teach children.
Computers don’t teach, it’s the instructor, program, web site, etc. that teaches. The computer is a window to everything so it’s important to guide children in the right direction. A chalkboard is used to teach not to play tic-tac-toe, hang-man and draw graffiti.
the_numbers_man