In the latest chapter in the saga of school vouchers in the District of Columbia, it seems as if the Catholic schools in DC need some extra money to help with the costs of public school students enrolling under the plan. The Archdiocese is asking for around $2 million from the federal government and private donations to cover the additional expenses that will come with the new students. While each child could receive a voucher of up to $7500, the plan will not pay more than the advertised tuition at the school. In the case of inner city DC Catholic schools that’s $3500 a year.
But this points up one of the big fallacies behind the cost of private education. Many voucher advocates love to point out that private schools do a better job of educating kids for less money. However, the big open secret of most private schools is that the tuition doesn’t cover the whole bill. In the case of DC Catholic schools, the $3500 fee is only about half of the actually cost of educating a student. In most private schools the balance is made up from a variety of fund rasing activities and lots of volunteer work (sometimes required "volunteerism") on the part of parents and often staff members.
My niece attended a very prestigious and very expensive private school for most of her K12 experience. But on top of writing very large checks for tuition each year, my brother and his wife were also expected to work the carnival, provide transportation, and make a few additional "donations" at times. The same scene occurs on a smaller scale at most private schools which makes the up-front tuition only one part of the equation of computing the cost of education – and vouchers.
And how is this any different from the numerous PTA fund-raisers at the public schools?
Very few PTAs raise the kind of money brought in by fund raising drives at private schools. The amount is a very small percentage of the total school budget. And in most schools I’ve seen, PTA money is not used for textbooks and teacher salaries.