In catching up on some reading over the break, an article about how the learning gap between racial groups is closing but not very fast reminded me that No Child Left Behind is coming up for renewal early next year.
Combining the information in this piece with other recent studies showing little real progress overall in the four years since NCLB was passed should give Congress something to think about.
But it probably won’t.
Now, I know that reforming an entrenched system like education in this country is a difficult process and needs more than four years to work.
However, NCLB isn’t about school reform. It’s all about the numbers.
As much as the law and it’s supporters talk about “research-based” instructional programs, there is no valid research that supports the concepts at the heart of this legislation.
No genuine improvement in student learning will be achieved by having kids prep for and take standardized tests and then threatening schools and teachers over the results.
There will also be little narrowing of the gaps between races until we acknowledge that school is only one part of the equation.
Poverty is a major factor that few NCLB supporters seem ready to discuss.
A higher percentage of minority children live in poverty. Which means most of them come to school with limited basic reading skills, poor nutrition and inadequate health care.
All of that works to put them behind middle and upper class students regardless of race, a gap that is almost impossible for schools alone to close.
Rather than just rubber stamping the renewal of the this one-size-fits-all, train wreck of a law, legislators need to throw the whole thing out.
And rather than starting again with a new law that imposes artificial and unreachable goals based on political catch phrases, they need to take a realistic look at the realities of life in 21st century America.